Aug 112011
 

For nine months my heart seized every time I heard sirens on my street because each scream convinced me that he’d finally made good on his wish to die.

He was my master first and my friend later. He was my Bill. I loved him so much; I loved him in every way I could think of considering that we were married to other people and never once touched in a manner that could have been seen as inappropriate. When after knowing each other for two years he came out to me as trans, I only loved him more.

The ‘net was still young but my dial-up modem eventually wheezed its way to sites that taught me what trans meant, and what issues someone who identified as he did was likely to face. Over the course of several months I watched with a thrill of wonder and pleasure as he cultivated gentler movements, a softer voice, longer hair. I learned the name he’d called himself in secret since he was a child. He tried on my shoes.

It would have been a miracle if he’d have been able to carry through with his plans but he was married to someone who could not have been any more different from me. She was in no way ready to deal with a transitioning spouse and he was in no way willing to give up his marriage. Thus began a period where he talked of nothing but death: his plans, his equipment, the effect he wanted it to have on his wife. Frantic, I demanded that he hand over all his razor blades and ratted him out to his wife and therapist. The latter did what she could. The former posited vaguely that his mood was bound to improve once the season changed. I wrung my hands and listened for the phone to ring after every siren.

Eventually he reached the conclusion that an intact marriage was the most important goal. He cut off his hair,  re-grew his beard and adopted an attitude of such insufferable assholery that I could take no more and began calling him on his shit. It was at that point that he removed from his life the people who had been the most accepting of his desire to transition. Including his therapist. Including me.

With the perspective of many years now I can forget about the pain of losing the relationship and remember only what he1 taught me, the tiniest fraction of which is this: Jokes at the expense of trans people just aren’t funny, and so when one popped up on a board I frequent on this site — a site which, mind you, is dedicated to the free exploration of consensual sexuality — I sent off a note to the comment’s author.

Who happened to be an assistant moderator on that particular board, a fact which I pointed out to him in my note. What example does it send to the rest of our members? I said. How do you think your comment would make a trans person reading our boards, or considering joining, feel? Would they feel welcome, I asked, and to his credit he immediately agreed to remove the “joke”. But then he spent the next half-hour arguing with me about it. “I’ve got black friends, Asian friends, gay friends,” he said, “and they all think my jokes are funny.” And “If someone’s going to be offended over a little joke they don’t belong in our group.” And “If 99 people think it’s funny and only one is offended, I’m going to go with the majority.” And I argued back despite being in tears because with every word he said I could only hear sirens screaming down my street.

We left off with polite words but when I checked back hours later not only was his original “joke” still there but it was also echoed and expanded upon by another group member. This time I went straight to the top; I made my case to the group’s main moderator with the final promise that if “jokes” like those were allowed to stay on our boards, I wouldn’t. I cannot watch this, I told her. I cannot by my silence give the impression of approval.

She gets it. The jokes are now gone. I won this round, but I have a feeling the next one won’t be so easy. I have a feeling that very soon my affiliation with that group will need to end, because I won’t — I can’t — sit by while  dehumanizing “jokes” at the expense of already marginalized communities go unchecked.

It’s a sin that somehow
Light is changing to shadow
And casting its shroud
Over all we have known

  1. I have used masculine pronouns throughout as this is where he ended up. I am not sure if this is the right answer in a situation like this but it feels the most respectful []
Jul 272011
 

We are driving to the swimming pool.

Kid 1: My feet are older than I am.

Me, fiddling with CD player: Mmm?

Kid 2: Your feet aren’t old.

Kid 1 (K1): My feet aren’t old, but they are older than me.

Me: Wait, what?

K1: My feet are older than me.

Me: Do you mean that your feet were born first? That they came out of my stomach first?

Kid 2 (K2): I grew in my birthmom’s stomach.

Kid 3 (K3): Yeah, I grew in my birthmom’s stomach too.

K2: Your birthmom is the same as my birthmom.

K3: I know that. Why did you think I didn’t know that? My birth dad is [xxxxx], but he’s not your birthdad.

K2: I know that. We don’t know my birthdad.

[K2 and K3 bickering continues.]

Me, mentally preparing lecture about typical logistics of birth: Do you mean that your feet came out of me first?

K1: No, gross. Wait, did they?

Me: No, your head came out first.

K1: Oh ok. But my feet are still older.

Me: How so?

K1: Well, my feet grew before I was born, right?

Me: Okay?

K1: And I wasn’t really me until I was born, right?

Me: Oh, I see what you mean. I guess if you count it that way then yes, your feet are definitely older than you are.

K1: What other way is there to count it?

Me: Well, most people who are interested in logic and science say that a fetus turns into an actual baby around the point when it can live independently, outside the mother. Most pregnancies last about forty weeks, but some babies who are born early, at around twenty-two or so weeks can also live. So by your reasoning, your feet are five or six months older than you are.

K1: Well I believe in science and logic, so that’s what I believe.

Me: Yes, that’s what our family believes. But not everyone thinks that way.

K1: Why wouldn’t they believe that?

Me: Some people believe that it’s a baby from the moment the sperm and egg come together.

K1: But it doesn’t even have organs! It doesn’t have a brain, or a heart!

Me: You can see a fetus’ heartbeat by the time the woman is eight weeks pregnant. I saw yours then.

K2: Did you see mine then?

Me: No, I didn’t see yours. I didn’t know N. then. But I saw your heart beating later.

K3: Did you see mine?

Me: No, N. was living in [xxxxxx] then.

K1: But having a heartbeat doesn’t mean it’s a person.

Me: That’s what I think. But not everyone thinks that way. Those are the people who believe that every single pregnancy should go to term no matter what.

K1: But what if the mother is, like, twelve years old [She is at this moment just barely twelve years old.] Do they think that mother should have to stay pregnant?

Me: Yes.

K1: But that’s so mean!

Me: There’s a passage in the Bible that says, essentially, that God knew you before you were born; that he knit you together in your mother’s womb. That’s a big part of why anti-choice people say that no pregnancy should be ended.

K1: That’s dumb.

Me: You might think it’s dumb, but lots of people believe that.

K1: But we don’t, right?

Me: Right, we don’t.

[We flash our pool passes at the desk.]

Me: Here’s the thing though. I had tests to check on how the everything was developing when I was first pregnant. If those tests had shown that there were abnormalities, that the baby wouldn’t have survived, or that it would have had a painful, difficult life, I would not have continued the pregnancy.

K1, jockeying for first sunblock-application position: Okay?

Me: But other people in the same position would choose to have a baby like that, and love it and raise it.

K1: Okay?

Me: This is what it means to be pro-choice. Every woman gets to decide for herself.

K1: Mom, I know.

And off she ran on her twelve-year-and-six-month-old feet.

May 162011
 

If I had a boy going on this trip I would so support him in wearing short-shorts and a halter top.

Also: Comic Sans.

Ridonkulous through and through.

May 022011
 

Despite the best efforts of a few1 commentors, and my mother, I feel very little shame over any sexual misconduct in which I am alleged to have indulged. Wait, let me check!

Right, still very little shame.

Somehow this has not carried over into other facets of my life where the guilt — oh how very deep does the guilt run. This is nowhere so evident than in the absolute misery I’ve put myself through these past several years over the state of my lawn.

My little family lives in a neighborhood that could only be described as working class. We are surrounded by cubicle-jockeys, teachers, assembly-linespeople, truck drivers and a healthy contingent of grannies. No one, and I mean no one, cares a whit about maintaining golfcourse-like grass. But we do, for the most part, keep things neat. We mow weekly, and when late July rolls around (and in defiance of all logic) we set out the sprinklers to keep things green. Before I bore or otherwise acquired  children I did the same; additionally, I surrounded the entire house and bordered every inch of fence with gardens, which I filled with all manner of flora from the ornamental to the edible. Vividly do I remember being so pregnant I could barely see my toes and digging up one last patch of grass. I need to get this done before the baby arrives, I remember thinking. If I get it planted now, maintaining it after she’s here won’t be so difficult.

For the most part I was right; with one child and no other employment I had time enough to weed and fertilize, and every day during the growing season — every day! — I walked through my tiny domain and scuffed out with the toe of my shoe any weed brazen enough to show its spiny head. I even had time to take pictures of my handiwork, pictures which I painstakingly edited and which, if you’ve been here with me from the start, you might recall seeing regularly long ago. But then life (in the shape of two babies in quick succession and the end of a marriage) intervened, and by the time my husband left the family home and I was expected to earn enough money to satisfy three ravenous children, weeding the garden fell lower and lower on my list until it fell right off.

Then the guilt began: Each intervening year saw the yard grow more disheveled and the gardens less beautiful. Grass overtook the borders of fist-sized granite chunks I’d so carefully placed and choked out my lovely flowers. A local teenager with a lawnmower and a need for gas money managed the regular lawn care but as time went on scuffing out weeds with the toe of my shoe became less and less possible until at some point a couple years ago I pretty much gave up and let the shame grow as rampant as the weeds, weeds that hid even my carefully painted giraffe.2

Clearly this commercial played beneath my playtime too many times during my formative years. I believed it:

I can rub and scrub this old house til it’s shinin’ like a dime.
Feed the baby, grease the car and powder my face at the same time.
Get all dressed up, go out and swing til 4 a.m.
And then lay down at 5, jump up at 6, and start all over again.

So irrational are my thoughts on this topic that while we are outside playing I fret that we’re not inside cleaning. While we’re inside cleaning I worry that I’m not giving them enough culture. If we enjoy something cultural I’m convinced that my work is falling by the wayside. As I work I think of the ten-thousand things I need from the store. Shopping, I beat myself up over the fact that I’m not pulling weeds. And so it goes, a never-ending litany of guilt that I can’t get done everything that needs to be done and no matter how hard I try, all that’s happened is that my eldest is two-thirds of the way to being raised and I’ve not had nearly enough time with her. There is never enough time. I will never have enough time.

So in the minivan I play this. Loudly. Repeatedly. I sing along3 — for myself as much as for them. I hope the chorus bores into their little developing brains ’til they know that perfection is neither attainable nor necessary and that their self-worth is tied not to the number of weeds in their flower beds but is instead a function of how well they treat other people. I hope they will know this. I hope they will know this better than do I.

There is but one solution to my weed problem: I have purchased a huge quantity of mulch and bottles of the strongest weed killer I could find. I have begun a schedule of weed-killin’ that I resolve to carry out throughout the warm months ’til even the stubbornest specimens succumb. I have hired a teenager whose back is certainly stronger than my own4 to place the mulch in each flowerbed and around any plants that are not killed outright. The combination of a thick layer of wood chips and ongoing herbicidal blitz will surely knock things back to the point that I will no longer die a tiny death at the number of dandelions in the grass or foot-tall foxtails amongst the lilies. And then maybe next year I can get back to more toe-scuffing and less soul-crushing shame.

Maybe.

  1. A merciful few, all things considered []
  2. This has not always been a bad thing. Right now the overgrown backyard is housing two pair of cardinals, a hideaway for the kids behind a seldom trimmed bush, and, next to the door, a mother duck warming a clutch of a dozen eggs. []
  3. Nervous messed up marionette, flying alone on a prison ship. [I know those lyrics are misquoted but that is how I hear them. I think they're better this way.] []
  4. Because he has not unloaded and spread out one-hundred bags of mulch a half-dozen times over the years []
 

At the moment he’s only making the request maybe once in every three opportunities but when he wants it, you’d better believe that my son gets the exact same crack as his sister at choosing a color and having me polish his nails. I allow — nay, encourage — this to demonstrate to my children and everyone who crosses their paths that there are very few things in this world exclusively in the domain of boy- or girl-hood, and that to react with shock and horror to a boy doing a traditionally “girl” activity is the rankest misogyny as it implies that there’s something weaker, lesser, more shameful about those things and the people who do them.

Did you miss out on Toemageddon Eleven? Have a look at a screenshot here. One Million Moms believes that this ad and little boy toenail-paintin’  are abominations which rip at the fabric of society and perhaps even that of the space-time continuum. Holy mother of God it might give children “ideas”:

Not only is it disappointing that J.Crew would encourage planting the seeds for gender identity, but it is even more offensive to have it sent to homes where other children may see this and get “ideas” that this is normal. [snip] As a mother to a son myself, I could not imagine encouraging behavior that is not a typical activity for a boy. Not only could this be harmful in the development of a boy, but it questions if a mother is satisfied with the gender her child was born with. If you have a son and are not sure what to do with a boy, you learn and learn fast! You cherish and embrace the gender of the child God has blessed you with. To carry out nontraditional activities with a boy to fulfill your own desires or dreams can be destructive and damaging to a child’s identity and self-esteem. A child should never feel that parents wished him or her to be a different gender. (I’m not linking to their post but it’s easy enough to find, if you care. It’s so over the top that you’ll wish it was a Poe. Alas it is not.)

I have to wonder how stridently the author encourages behavior that is a “typical activity for a boy,” because as the mother of boy myself I can tell you that if I allowed it, his “typical” activity would mainly revolve around scribbling with permanent marker on the carpeting, crashing tiny cars into the woodwork, bopping his sisters (and the cats) on the head and bellowing like an overwrought buffalo while at all times maintaining a death-grip on his penis. What does go on in her house?

Does the Bible demand that the owners of y-chromosomes eschew nail polish? Why yes it does!

The woman shall not wear that which pertaineth unto a man, neither shall a man put on a woman’s garment: for all that do so are abomination unto the LORD thy God. (Deuteronomy 22)

Of course that chapter also requires that a virgin unfortunate enough to find herself sexually assaulted within the walls of a city must be stoned to death:

If a damsel that is a virgin be betrothed unto an husband, and a man find her in the city, and lie with her;

Then ye shall bring them both out unto the gate of that city, and ye shall stone them with stones that they die; the damsel, because she cried not, being in the city; and the man, because he hath humbled his neighbour’s wife: so thou shalt put away evil from among you.

So, you know, take Deuteronomy with a grain of salt.

Somewhere in this world right now there is a little boy whose fondest wish is to wear every shade of glittery pink in his clothing and on his nails — and that child is being raised by a Million Mom. This is just one of the very many reasons I’ve given up the idea of a god who takes an interest in our tiny affairs (or any god at all), because if there were a god he would have given this child to me or someone like me, someone who would have embraced his glitteriness with nothing but love.

If you’d like to counteract the force of a million moms (funny, however, that only 3% of those “million moms” have liked their own Facebook page!), take a moment to call J Crew (1-800-562-0258; press 2 for customer service). Alternately, if you go to their site you will, in a few minutes, be offered the chance to live-chat with a rep. I called around 9 last night and was immediately connected to a lovely rep who seemed more than a little relieved to hear some positive feedback.

 

Nothing in the world is the way it ought to be.
It’s harsh, and cruel. But that’s why there’s us.
Champions.
It doesn’t matter where we come from, what we’ve done or suffered, or
even if we make a difference. We live as though the world were as it
should be, to show it what it can be. You’re not a part of that yet.
I hope you will be.

It is no exaggeration to say that I am terrified for the kind of future my children will grow up in if even some of these things come to pass:

1) Republicans not only want to reduce women’s access to abortion care, they’re actually trying to redefine rape. After a major backlash, they promised to stop. But they haven’t yet. Shocker.

2) A state legislator in Georgia wants to change the legal term for victims of rape, stalking, and domestic violence to “accuser.” But victims of other less gendered crimes, like burglary, would remain “victims.”

3) In South Dakota, Republicans proposed a bill that could make it legal to murder a doctor who provides abortion care. (Yep, for real.)

4) Republicans want to cut nearly a billion dollars of food and other aid to low-income pregnant women, mothers, babies, and kids.

5) In Congress, Republicans have a bill that would let hospitals allow a woman to die rather than perform an abortion necessary to save her life.

6) Maryland Republicans ended all county money for a low-income kids’ preschool program. Why? No need, they said. Women should really be home with the kids, not out working.

7) And at the federal level, Republicans want to cut that same program, Head Start, by $1 billion. That means over 200,000 kids could lose their spots in preschool.

8) Two-thirds of the elderly poor are women, and Republicans are taking aim at them too. A spending bill would cut funding for employment services, meals, and housing for senior citizens.

9) Congress just voted for a Republican amendment to cut all federal funding from Planned Parenthood health centers, one of the most trusted providers of basic health care and family planning in our country.

10) And if that wasn’t enough, Republicans are pushing to eliminate all funds for the only federal family planning program. (For humans. But Republican Dan Burton has a bill to provide contraception for wild horses. You can’t make this stuff up).

Each item above is cited here; click to read more details then please find your legislators’ contact information and contact them today.

And tomorrow.

And the next day.

Then put your money where your mouth is and donate to Planned Parenthood today. I did.1

  1. Just a few dollars, nothing really. But a bunch of people donating just a few dollars adds up, so please do. []
 

Emphasis mine:

Anal sex is painful, unsanitary, unsatisfying for women and creates unique risks for serious physical diseases (if you doubt me, go read the Wikipedia entry on the subject) because the anus is not designed for sexual intercourse, increasing the risk of torn flesh and the intermingling of bodily fluids—blood, semen, fecal matter—that can spread an astonishing variety of diseases. The female partner is far more at risk than the man in these encounters. This should be a feminist issue.

–Maggie Gallagher (read the rest here with blood pressure medicine close at hand)

I couldn’t agree with you more, Ms. Gallagher. Anal sex should be a feminist issue, and here’s how it would go: My feminine body is my own, and I will do to my anus whatever I choose with no supremely ignorant judgment from you on how painful, unsanitary or unsatisfying you might guess it to be.

Nov 172010
 

The kid came home at noon, puking, so after an afternoon spent huddled over a bowl she saw her siblings off to swim lessons then begged indulgence to choose her own television show. Slim pickings tonight, doll, I told her.

“SpongeBob?” she moaned.

Nope, your choices are antiques or dancing. She didn’t even ask for an explanation of the former choice; as soon as the music started she leapt from her sickbed and pasodobled right along with Brandy.

“Mommy, her dress is so pretty!” she said, sickness all but forgotten in a fluff of feathers and sequined shoes.

Mmm. I said. I bet they’ve practiced so hard to learn this dance. And then it cut to commercial, a pre-Christmas shill geared toward men considering popping the question at some point during the holidays.

She was transfixed. “Mommy, I want a ring just like that!”

I was horrified. Despite media consumption carefully controlled to avoid most references to happily ever after or a rescue by prince charming had she somehow absorbed those forbidden messages from the aether? Was she going to turn into a child obsessed with white dresses, flowers and veils? Had I failed at nurturing a strong little protofeminist?

Why do you want a ring like that? I almost didn’t want to know.

She shot me a look that suggested I was too stupid to bother answering. Very slowly she answered: “I want it because it’s shiny.”

Shiny. My relief knew no bounds. It certainly is shiny. How do you suppose you could get a ring like that?

Now her look was a tiny bit more polite. “Do you have one you could give me?”

My heart gave a minor lurch as I thought of my own shiny ring tucked away in a drawer, neglected for years and years even before the end of that relationship. I denied ownership of any such ring.

Nevertheless she brightened. “I know! I’ll get a job when I grow up! Then I can buy all those rings!” She thrust her hands into my face. “I’m going to buy a ring for every finger!”

Good girl, I thought. I think that’s a really good plan, I said.

Independence success.

 

Over the past few weeks my long-suffering Twitter followers have tolerated my complaints about a poison which until recently has lurked undetected in my pantry and refrigerator, a poison that for the past almost-year has upset my stomach so terribly that sharing any details would be just rude.

So I won’t1.

Clearing out that poison from my system (if not from the pantry, as no one else in the family is affected) has brought about a change that is nothing short of miraculous. The time freed up that once was spent in the bathroom2! The energy regained! The ever-so-slightly-decreased sense of all-pervasive self-loathing! Glory be!

As a not unwelcome side effect, the ban on glutens has forced me to be more cognizant of what I put in my mouth. Just two weeks later my pants fit better and were I to gather the courage necessary to set foot upon the scale I have no doubt that it would report back a number marginally less soul-crushing than the last time I was so bold.

So on a beautiful fall afternoon after triumphantly scoring some non-poisonous cornbread mix from the local health-food store my son and I stopped by a park just off one of my town’s main thoroughfares as a reward for his not poking sticky3 little fingers into every bulk bin. At one in the afternoon we were the only ones there; I watched the child gambol and cavort, as almost-happy as anyone with my particular disposition and set of mental health issue could ever hope to be, until some jackhole leaned his upper body completely out of his car window and shouted “Fatass!” in my general direction before speeding bravely away.

What are we to make of this charming young man? Here are some possibilities. He might have been:

  1. Raised by wolves.
  2. Hard-of-seeing, as it’s patently obvious that my ass is the least egregiously un-thin part of me.
  3. A devotee of Marie Claire magazine.
  4. Unaware of the unrelenting fat-hatred dished out minute by minute to which he was contributing:
  5. If you’re fat, you’re not only meant to be unhappy, but deeply ashamed of yourself, projecting at all times an apologetic nature, indicative of your everlasting remorse for having wrought your monstrous self upon the world. You are certainly not meant to be bold, or assertive, or confident—and should you manage to overcome the constant drumbeat of messages that you are ugly and unsexy and have earned equally society’s disdain and your own self-hatred, should you forget your place and walk into the world one day with your head held high, you are to be reminded by the cow-calls and contemptuous looks of perfect strangers that you are not supposed to have self-esteem; you don’t deserve it. Being publicly fat and happy is hard; being publicly, shamelessly, unshakably fat and happy is an act of both will and bravery. (It is definitely worth reading the rest of the post here.)

    –or–

  6. All of the above.

It’s a painful reminder that no matter how many amazing things I do with my life, no matter how successfully I mother or love or write, no matter how vigilantly I work to manage body and mind — to a certain set of people I can be nothing more than a “fatass.” No doubt it was meant to be a reminder, a reminder that in that young man’s reasoning the only version of womanhood worthy to be seen is the kind capable of bringing on an erection.

I am not that. Therefore I should not exist; not anywhere, and certainly not at a park where I could be seen by him.

And I wonder, when I can’t stop myself from thinking down this path, what precisely would change in my mind should this whole gluten thing bring on enough of a weight loss that I’d no longer be subject to that kind of negative attention? Would I, once thin, attract a different set of potential partners? If I caught the eye of some skinny-girl-loving-man, would I ever be able to trust him?

Or would I look into his eyes and wonder if he was the one who yelled?

  1. you should be very, very thankful for this []
  2. whoopsie, we are not talking about this []
  3. and possibly gluten-covered []
 

My overwhelming impulse is to take her by the shoulders and scream in her face Get your goddamn tubes tied right now, but being pro-choice means accepting others’ reproductive decisions without trying to impose my own.

But oh how I wish I could do that, or barring that I wish I could march her to the nearest Planned Parenthood clinic so that this pregnancy could be terminated immediately because to be perfectly honest that’s what I’ve wished for her to choose with each and every pregnancy she’s fallen into since the first. If you’re counting (and who wouldn’t be, as it is as horrifyingly fascinating as the worst tales of bodily oddities), she’s been pregnant five times in the past six years and has been able successfully to parent none of the resultant children.

None of them.

“I know a couple,” said the mother of N’s latest child when once she’d been filled in on this most recent development. “They’re a great couple, a Christian couple, and they’ve been trying for so long …”

Oh dear god, I thought through the phone. Please stop talking. Please stop talking right now.

She didn’t stop. “I know they’d love to have this baby. Do you think I should tell N. about them and see what she thinks?”

No! I said, and I’m sure my voice was not kind. You cannot talk to her about potential adoptive parents until she’s decided what she wants to do. She could decide to terminate the pregnancy 1 . Or she might decide to try to parent. If she eventually decides to place the baby, that’s when you can bring up your friends. Not before. And I swore to myself that if she disregarded my warning I would add her to my list of People To Yell At or turn her into the Adoption Police or at least be very, very angry.

Because very, very angry is what I am about every aspect of this situation. Not that my emotions much matter. I am pro-choice — most days even stoically pro-choice — so I will hold my tongue while N. sorts out her plans for this pregnancy, and once done I’ll lend support no matter what her choice.

  1. Would you be surprised to know that it is possible to hear indignant bristling through a phone line? []

Find Me Here



Receive Updates Via Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner